Cover of The Mushroom Tapes by Helen Garner, Chloe Hooper and Sarah Krasnostein
Bestseller

The Mushroom Tapes

Helen Garner, Chloe Hooper and Sarah Krasnostein

Published in Australia

True Crime
Text Publishing · 11 November 2025

Short review

Three of Australia's most admired nonfiction writers joined forces for The Mushroom Tapes, an unconventional book about the case that gripped the country: the trial of Erin Patterson, who in July 2025 was convicted of murdering three relatives and attempting to murder a fourth with a lunch containing death cap mushrooms.

Helen Garner, Chloe Hooper and Sarah Krasnostein attended the ten-week trial in Morwell, Victoria, and recorded their conversations as they travelled to and from court. The book is built from those exchanges, with the three authors questioning what they saw, what they felt and why so many people, themselves included, became fixated on the case.

The result is less a conventional courtroom narrative than a thoughtful, often funny and deeply humane discussion of crime, gender, family and storytelling. The authors are frank about the ethics of turning real tragedy into entertainment, and keep the victims and the affected children firmly in view. Published by Text, it was the number one bestseller of 2025 at Melbourne's Readings bookshops. It is an essential read for true crime fans who want more than sensation.

Sources and retailer details (182 words)

Full review

The Erin Patterson trial was one of the most closely followed criminal cases in Australian history. In July 2023, Patterson served a lunch in Leongatha, Victoria, after which three of her guests died and a fourth fell gravely ill from death cap mushroom poisoning. In July 2025, after a ten-week trial in Morwell, she was found guilty of three murders and one attempted murder; she has since been sentenced to life imprisonment and has lodged an appeal.

Among the writers in the public gallery were Helen Garner, Chloe Hooper and Sarah Krasnostein, three of the country's leading literary nonfiction authors. Rather than each writing a separate account, they recorded their conversations, originally with a podcast in mind, during the long drives between Melbourne and the courthouse. The Mushroom Tapes, published by Text in November 2025, is the result, and it topped the 2025 bestseller list at Readings, the Melbourne bookseller.

The conversational format is the book's great strength. The three authors challenge each other, change their minds and admit their own discomfort at being drawn into a spectacle. They discuss motive and evidence, but also media behaviour, the appetite for true crime, and what it means to make literature from other people's grief. Throughout, they show real compassion for the victims, the survivor and the children caught up in the case.

Readers wanting a definitive, chronological account of the trial may find the structure loose. But as an intelligent, candid study of why such stories grip us, it stands apart from the rest of the genre.

Write a review

Write a review

Please note

The review must be your own independent reading of the book: you must not be the author, related to the author, or work for its publisher.

Every review is checked automatically. We decline reviews that are overly negative, that reveal the plot, or that include swearing or other harmful language. Fair criticism written constructively is welcome.

If your review passes the check, the review text may be published on that book’s page on this site. Your name and email are never published; we use them only to identify you if you are selected for paid review work.

Your review

About 80–1500 words. Do not reveal the plot or ending.

About you

Required so we can identify you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published on the site.

Required so we can identify you and contact you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published.

We’ll show you the sign-up box on the next page.

We select paid part-time reviewers from people who submit reviews here. Payments vary by book length and review length.

We use your details as described in our Privacy Policy.

Similar books in this genre

Bestseller

London Falling

Patrick Radden Keefe

True Crime

Patrick Radden Keefe, the author of Say Nothing and Empire of Pain, is one of the finest narrative journalists working today, and London Falling keeps…

Read review
Bestseller

The Best Kind of American

Kim Ghattas

True Crime

Kim Ghattas, the Beirut-born journalist behind Black Wave, turns a cold case into a sweeping history in The Best Kind of American.

Read review
Bestseller

Sleuth-Hound

Lindsey Fitzharris

True Crime

Lindsey Fitzharris, the medical historian behind The Butchering Art and The Facemaker, brings her talent for grisly, gripping storytelling to the birth of…

Read review