
Peck & Peck
Short review
Bonnie Garmus's Lessons in Chemistry was one of the publishing phenomena of the decade and became an Apple TV series. Her second novel swaps the 1960s chemistry lab for 1982 New York and the most prestigious, secretive and dysfunctional poetry quarterly in the world. Batter Gray is a recent graduate with an unmarketable gift, an "ear" for poetry. He is folding T-shirts at the Gap until he lands a job at Peck & Peck, where twin editors-in-chief are at war and the house motto is "Find originality. Reward creativity. Burn the rest."
It is a premise made for Garmus's comic sensibility, and the early verdicts are affectionate. Kirkus finds it "mostly charming, sometimes twee, with some really lovely things to say about poetry." Kirkus also notes that the novel bogs down in the middle before picking up steam towards the end, a fair warning for impatient readers.
There is a lot here for book lovers, not least the premise itself: a satire of literary gatekeeping told with obvious love for poetry. It will not hit with the cultural force of her debut, but it confirms that Garmus's voice was no one-off. It is a warm, clever choice for readers who like their literary fiction funny.




