
The Killer Isn't Alice
Short review
The murder-puzzle boom we flagged last week has a new front-runner. Iris Starling's The Killer Isn't Alice first appeared in February 2026. After a 16-way UK auction and a Little, Brown deal in the US, a revised edition is now No. 4 across all books on Amazon UK and No. 4 on Publishers Weekly's trade paperback list.
The hook is in the subtitle: 46,600 suspects and one killer. Alice Starling is missing, and the police have found a body, a cryptic note and a folder of names. Alice leaves you 18 clues, and your job is to eliminate everyone who fails to fit until one name remains.
Where Murdle and Murdoku offer dozens of short cases, this is one sustained investigation, closer to an escape room in book form. The revised edition adds new graphics, a new culprit and a bonus puzzle. The story is thin by design, so readers who want atmosphere should stick to crime novels. For lovers of deduction, it is an ingenious challenge and an obvious Christmas present.
Sources and retailer details (173 words)
Chart & sources
- Amazon UK Books #4 overall, checked Nov 2 2026
- Publishers Weekly Trade Paperback #4 (8 weeks on list), week ended Oct 24 2026 (PW Nov 2 2026 list)
- Amazon US Books #22 overall, checked Nov 2 2026
- The Bookseller (Oct 27 2026): UK Non-Fiction Paperback #1
- Author site
- The Bookseller (Jun 25 2026): Century acquires after 16-way auction
Full review
The murder-puzzle boom we flagged last week has a new front-runner. Iris Starling's The Killer Isn't Alice first appeared in February 2026. After a 16-way auction in the UK, reported by The Bookseller, and a Little, Brown deal in the US, a revised edition is now on both sides of the Atlantic. It is No. 4 across all books on Amazon UK and No. 4 on Publishers Weekly's trade paperback list.
The hook is in the subtitle: 46,600 suspects and one killer. Alice Starling is missing, and in her apartment the police find a dead body, a cryptic note and a folder of names. Alice protests her innocence and leaves you 18 clues. Your job is to work through the list methodically, eliminating everyone who fails to fit, until a single name satisfies every condition.
Where Murdle and Murdoku offer dozens of bite-sized cases, this is one sustained investigation. That makes it feel closer to an escape room in book form, a project to return to over several evenings rather than a quick puzzle on the train. The revised edition adds updated graphics, a new culprit and a bonus puzzle, so owners of the original are not simply buying the same book twice.
Its narrative is thin by design: the story exists to frame the deduction. Readers who want characters and atmosphere should stick with conventional crime fiction. But for anyone who loves the logic of a whodunnit, it is an ingenious, absorbing challenge, and it makes an obvious Christmas present for the puzzler who has everything.


