
Murder Most Cryptic
Published in the United Kingdom
Short review
Crime and crosswords collide in Alys Cummings's debut, a puzzle mystery reviewed in The Guardian's October crime round-up and a natural fit for fans of Murdle and Richard Osman. Cummings, a former local newspaper journalist and BBC Panorama staffer from the north-east of England, brings both newsroom savvy and a setter's mischief to the page.
Nina is a promising young journalist who is also an alcoholic. Once a week she attends a recovery group in a church hall. One night a stranger walks in, and the group assume he is a new member, until he promptly drops dead. The police see nothing more than an accident, but in the dead man's pocket is a cryptic crossword clue whose answer is Murder. When more threatening clues begin appearing in a newspaper crossword, Nina and her fellow group members decide to crack the case themselves.
The clues are woven through the story for readers to solve, with answers provided, which makes the book unusually interactive. What gives it depth is the honest portrayal of addiction and recovery beneath the fun. It is a clever, warm and distinctive debut. Sharpen your pencils.
Sources and retailer details (189 words)
Full review
Murder Most Cryptic is the debut novel of Alys Cummings, a journalist who worked on local newspapers, for a news agency at the Old Bailey and for BBC Panorama. Published by Michael Joseph in October and featured in Laura Wilson's Guardian crime round-up, it is a puzzle mystery with a genuinely fresh hook: the clues are cryptic crossword clues, and readers can try to solve them alongside the characters.
The heroine, Nina, is a talented young reporter and a recovering alcoholic who goes to a weekly support group in a local church hall. When an unfamiliar man joins one evening, everyone assumes he has come for help. Moments later he collapses and dies. The police conclude it was an accident, but the group find a crossword clue in his pocket, and the answer is Murder. More clues then start to appear in a newspaper's crossword, each more menacing than the last, and the group realise one of them could be next.
Cummings plays fair with her puzzles, building them into the narrative and supplying the solutions at the end, so solvers and non-solvers alike can enjoy the ride. The cast of misfits is likeable, and their shared struggles with addiction lend the story more emotional weight than the average cosy mystery. There is a darker edge, too, as the threats escalate.
The tone occasionally wobbles between light-hearted puzzling and serious subject matter, and the plot leans on coincidence at times. Still, this is an inventive, entertaining debut, ideal for anyone who starts the day with a crossword and ends it with a whodunnit.


