Cover of Serenity Falls by C. J. Tudor

Serenity Falls

C. J. Tudor

Published in the United Kingdom

Horror
Michael Joseph · 10 September 2026

Short review

C. J. Tudor, the British author behind The Chalk Man and The Burning Girls, turns her eye on the American dream in Serenity Falls, a creepy slow-burn chiller that was featured in The Guardian's September round-up of the best new horror.

Widower Dan and his daughter Sadie leave a troubled past in England for a fresh start in Serenity Falls, a planned community in Florida that prides itself on having no crime at all. The houses are pristine, the neighbours are friendly and the lawns are perfect. Then a dead body turns up in their swimming pool, and it soon emerges that this idyllic town has seen a surprising number of unfortunate accidents in its fifty-year history.

Tudor is excellent at the gradual creep of wrongness: abandoned houses, odd behaviour and polite smiles that hide something. The father-daughter relationship gives the book an emotional anchor, and her dark humour keeps the pages turning. Comparisons with The Stepford Wives and classic Stephen King are earned. It is a satisfying pick for readers who like their horror suburban, mysterious and steadily unnerving.

Sources and retailer details (180 words)

Full review

C. J. Tudor has built a strong following with The Chalk Man, The Burning Girls and The Drift, novels that sit somewhere between crime and horror. Serenity Falls, published by Michael Joseph in September and reviewed by Lisa Tuttle in The Guardian's round-up of recent horror, is one of her most enjoyable books yet, swapping English villages for the manicured lawns of Florida.

The premise is classic. Dan, a widower, and his daughter Sadie move from the UK to Serenity Falls, a carefully planned community that boasts of having no crime. It seems the perfect place to start again. Almost immediately, though, a body is discovered in their pool, and as Dan starts asking questions he learns that the town has a long record of fatal accidents stretching back over its fifty years. As the community prepares to celebrate its anniversary, more odd discoveries pile up, from empty houses to unexplained activity at night.

Tudor's great skill is in making the ordinary sinister. Neighbourly kindness feels like surveillance, and rules that seem quaint gradually look like something worse. She balances suspense with warmth, particularly in the relationship between Dan and Sadie, and with the wry humour that runs through her work.

The book is long, and the middle section occasionally lingers, but the payoff is worth the wait. It will appeal to fans of Stephen King's small-town horror, Ira Levin's The Stepford Wives and anyone who has ever suspected that a town seemed too good to be true.

Reader review (1)

Reviews from visitors. Checked automatically; names are not shown.

A reader ·

I was lucky to discover C. J. Tudor when she was about to publish her first book, almost nine years ago, and she has become a favourite of mine. She writes stories that combine horror and thriller elements, and she has been compared to Stephen King, who is a strong influence on her, for good reason. I haven’t been disappointed by any of her books yet, and her newest novel is no different. Imagine you are a single father, a teacher who has lost his job for defending his teenage daughter, and who has no idea what to do now. And, out of nowhere, you get a surprise inheritance from your mother, who always lived modestly and never talked about making any purchases abroad. But, she has left you a house in the USA. A luxury property, with a swimming pool and all. The house is in Serenity Falls, a unique place born from the mind of a man who created some of the most beloved children's animation movies, cartoon characters, and amusement parks in the world. His vision was to create a series of towns all over the USA, where families would feel safe and happy; nothing dangerous or bad would ever happen, and life would be perfect. It sounds too good to be true, and you soon discover that there is a catch, or several. You cannot sell the property, and you have to move there (Dan and Sadie, the protagonists, live in the UK at the beginning of the story) and live there for several years before you can think of selling the property. But, you don’t have any better options, so you move there. And you soon discover that 'nothing ever happens in Serenity Falls’ is open to interpretation, to say the least. The novel is narrated by a variety of characters —readers need not worry about getting confused, as the narrator is clearly indicated in each chapter— although the main protagonists are Dan and Sadie, his daughter. Sadie’s point of view is told in the third person, and all the rest are narrated in the first person. Although in the beginning we don’t know who everybody is, as the story progresses we get used to the characters, and we learn a lot of what has happened in Serenity Falls, things that Dan and Sadie do not know of- so we might feel we are in a privileged position, but, as is expected of the genre, not everything is revealed, and there are clues and red herrings galore. From what I am saying, you will probably get the idea that strange things are happening in the town, and that would be an understatement. The nasty surprises and the menacing characters and events keep coming, fast and thick, and the protagonists have no time to adapt and settle to their new life in between all the incidents they experience. On the surface, everything seems quiet and peaceful in the dream town, but as happens with the lake on the outskirts, there might be things hiding in the deep that are more dangerous than anybody would care to admit. As is the case with all of the author’s novels, there is plenty going on to keep readers turning the pages and wondering what might be happening. The characters are interesting and recognisable (I particularly like Sadie, who understands and knows much more than she lets on and is not afraid to push the boundaries and explore), and although sometimes we might wish Dan was a bit more determined and forceful, his love for his daughter and his determination to do the best for her comes across clearly. There is a full cast of secondary characters, who are fascinating as well, and some that we only hear about but never meet in person, at least. And then, there is the town, which is a character in its own right, perhaps the most important. The writing flows well, and it helps us understand and know the characters through their dialogue and internal monologues. There are scary moments (although I would not class the novel as pure horror), and there is plenty of dark humour, which eases the tension. I’ve highlighted many quotable paragraphs, and the ending is more than satisfying. Happy? Well, like my favourite horror movies and books, let’s say the ending leaves you with a feeling of uneasiness. To those of you who like to play detective and guess who and what is behind the events and discover all the secrets, you’d do well to reserve some time to read it without too many interruptions, so you don’t miss any clues. (I guessed some of the main secrets, but the beauty is in how they fit in the larger scheme of things. And I won’t say anything else). I recommend this book to readers of C. J. Tudor’s novels, Stephen King’s followers, and anybody who likes the sound of the story, even if they aren’t habitual readers of horror novels. There are plenty of bad things that take place in the book, of course, but anybody who enjoys reading thrillers won’t be scared or find it excessive. And readers who haven’t met this author before, check them all out and start wherever you like. They are all great!

Buy on AmazonWrite a review

Write a review

Please note

The review must be your own independent reading of the book: you must not be the author, related to the author, or work for its publisher.

Every review is checked automatically. We decline reviews that are overly negative, that reveal the plot, or that include swearing or other harmful language. Fair criticism written constructively is welcome.

If your review passes the check, the review text may be published on that book’s page on this site. Your name and email are never published; we use them only to identify you if you are selected for paid review work.

Your review

About 80–1500 words. Do not reveal the plot or ending.

About you

Required so we can identify you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published on the site.

Required so we can identify you and contact you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published.

We’ll show you the sign-up box on the next page.

We select paid part-time reviewers from people who submit reviews here. Payments vary by book length and review length.

We use your details as described in our Privacy Policy.

Similar books in this genre

Our Cut of Salt

Deena Helm

Horror

Deena Helm's debut is a haunted house novel with a difference: the house stands in Haifa, and the haunting is bound up with the Nakba of 1948.

Read review
Bestseller

From the Library of Jurgen Leitner

Premee Mohamed with Jonathan Sims

Horror

From the Library of Jurgen Leitner takes one of the most notorious institutions in the horror podcast The Magnus Archives and opens its doors.

Read review
Bestseller

Sometimes I Scare Myself

Jeneva Rose

Horror

Jeneva Rose made her name with twisty domestic thrillers, and in Sometimes I Scare Myself she steps confidently into horror with three linked-in-spirit…

Read review
Bestseller

Trad Wife

Sarah Langan

Horror

Sarah Langan, author of Good Neighbors, has a knack for finding the horror hidden inside the things people post online, and Trad Wife may be her most timely…

Read review