Cover of The Witch by Freida McFadden
Bestseller

The Witch

Freida McFadden

Mystery/Thriller/Suspense
Poisoned Pen Press (Sourcebooks) · 6 October 2026

Short review

Freida McFadden has become one of the defining thriller brands of the decade, and The Witch nudges her twist-driven domestic suspense towards the gothic. After three weeks on the US hardcover chart it has slipped to No. 7 on Publishers Weekly's hardcover list, but the ebook is No. 2 in Amazon's entire US Kindle Store and No. 6 in the UK Kindle chart.

Julia Barlow, out of a job and an apartment, retreats to Pemberton, her family's seventeenth-century estate in rural Massachusetts. Then the grandfather clock starts stopping at 3:41 every morning and a voice cries for help outside her door. The house's history leads her to a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692.

That dual timeline is the main attraction, and the historical strand gives the book more texture than some of her recent work; Booklist praised its "breathtaking twin climaxes". Whether the haunting is real is a question we will leave open. As ever, character depth comes second to momentum, and readers who find her twists mechanical will not be converted. For fans, it is a quick, atmospheric read for darker evenings.

Sources and retailer details (185 words)

Full review

Freida McFadden has become one of the defining thriller brands of the decade, and The Witch shows her stretching in a new direction. Only her second hardcover original, it nudges her twist-driven domestic suspense towards the gothic. After three weeks on the US hardcover chart it has slipped from the top to No. 7 on Publishers Weekly's list, but the ebook is now No. 2 in Amazon's entire US Kindle Store and No. 1 in its mystery and thriller chart. In the UK it is No. 6 in the Kindle chart.

Julia Barlow, out of a job and an apartment, retreats to Pemberton, her family's seventeenth-century estate in rural Massachusetts, ostensibly to look after her ageing grandmother. Then the grandfather clock starts stopping at 3:41 every morning, the lights flicker and a voice cries for help outside her door. Digging into the house's history leads her to a woman executed for witchcraft in 1692.

The dual timeline is the book's main attraction, and the historical strand gives it more texture than some of McFadden's recent work. Booklist praised its "breathtaking twin climaxes". Whether the haunting is real is a question the novel keeps deliberately open, and we will not answer it here.

As always with McFadden, character depth comes second to momentum. Short chapters and a steady supply of reveals are the point, and readers who find her twists mechanical are unlikely to be converted. For her many fans, though, and for anyone wanting a quick, atmospheric read for the darker evenings, it delivers exactly what it promises.

Reader review (1)

Reviews from visitors. Checked automatically; names are not shown.

A reader ·

Review The Witch by Freida McFadden presents an intriguing story filled with mystery, suspense and disturbing secrets. The novel explores the relationship between the past and present through the experiences of Julia Barlow, whose return to her family's old estate introduces her to a history she never expected to uncover. The story's central mystery revolves around an old witchcraft accusation and the disturbing events surrounding the family estate. This premise creates an atmosphere of uncertainty and encourages readers to question the difference between superstition, reality and hidden truths. One particularly interesting element is the connection between historical injustice and modern family secrets. The story raises questions about how fear, rumours and false accusations can influence people's lives across generations. The mysterious setting also adds considerable appeal to the story. An old family estate, unexplained occurrences and a troubling historical connection provide the foundation for an engaging psychological mystery. Overall Impression The Witch has an intriguing premise that should appeal to readers who enjoy psychological thrillers, historical mysteries and stories involving unexpected secrets. Its combination of suspense, family history and supernatural elements makes it an interesting title for mystery lovers. Conclusion Freida McFadden's The Witch offers an interesting exploration of mystery, fear and the lasting influence of the past. It is a promising choice for readers looking for a suspenseful story with historical connections.

Write a review

Please note

The review must be your own independent reading of the book: you must not be the author, related to the author, or work for its publisher.

Every review is checked automatically. We decline reviews that are overly negative, that reveal the plot, or that include swearing or other harmful language. Fair criticism written constructively is welcome.

If your review passes the check, the review text may be published on that book’s page on this site. Your name and email are never published; we use them only to identify you if you are selected for paid review work.

Your review

About 80–1500 words. Do not reveal the plot or ending.

About you

Required so we can identify you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published on the site.

Required so we can identify you and contact you if you are selected for paid review work. Never published.

We’ll show you the sign-up box on the next page.

We select paid part-time reviewers from people who submit reviews here. Payments vary by book length and review length.

We use your details as described in our Privacy Policy.

Similar books in this genre

Bestseller

The French Illusion

John Grisham

Mystery/Thriller/Suspense

John Grisham leaves the courtroom behind in The French Illusion, and readers have followed him.

Read review
Company Pick

The Hope Trigger

Deborah Riley-Magnus

Company Pick — reviewed by BooksGoSocial

Mystery/Thriller/Suspense

Max Caine is the operative people call when someone has been taken: a paramilitary kidnap and ransom specialist with sharp instincts and senses that make…

Read review
Company Pick

The Ghost of Downing Street

Mervyn Lovatt

Company Pick — reviewed by BooksGoSocial

Mystery/Thriller/Suspense

The Ghost of Downing Street is an ambitious, inventive thriller that transforms Britain’s most famous political address into a labyrinth of murder,…

Read review
Bestseller

The Hollow

Michael Connelly

Mystery/Thriller/Suspense

The Hollow sends Harry Bosch back to the place that shaped him.

Read review