
The French Illusion
Short review
John Grisham leaves the courtroom behind in The French Illusion, and readers have followed him. Six weeks after publication it is No. 5 on Publishers Weekly's hardcover fiction list, having peaked at No. 2, and it tops Amazon's US espionage thriller chart.
Paul and Chelsea Tanner are on their honeymoon in Paris when they vanish during a day trip. Ransom demands of $2 million arrive, first for one family and then the other, and the parents scramble to raise the money without telling the authorities. The FBI and CIA soon realise this is not an isolated crime: other honeymooning couples have been taken, and the grooms all share a military past.
From there the book becomes an undercover operation, as CIA agent Rae Claire Russo and former Guantanamo prosecutor Stuart Nash agree to marry and act as bait. Kirkus found it irresistible; a student reviewer at the Daily Northwestern was disappointed. Expect dark captivity scenes and a quick, cinematic pace rather than legal intrigue.
Sources and retailer details (164 words)
Full review
Thirty-plus years after The Firm, John Grisham is still willing to try something new. The French Illusion is not a legal thriller at all but an international kidnapping and terrorism story, and Kirkus suggests that newcomers might think he had been writing this kind of book all his life.
The opening is brutally effective. Paul and Chelsea Tanner disappear during a day trip on their Paris honeymoon, and a ransom of $2 million is demanded from Chelsea's wealthy parents, then the same sum from Paul's much less comfortable family. Grisham is good on the private panic of the parents, the decision to keep the press and police out, and the lies needed to keep friends from asking questions.
Then the scope widens. An FBI deputy director knows this is the third active case involving honeymooners whose husbands served in the armed forces, and the motive seems to be revenge as much as money. The second half follows CIA agent Rae Claire Russo and Stuart Nash, a former Justice Department prosecutor at Guantanamo Bay, who agree to marry so they can serve as bait.
Not everyone is convinced. A Daily Northwestern reviewer came away disillusioned, and some captivity scenes are grim. But the market has spoken: the book reached No. 2 on Publishers Weekly's hardcover fiction list, is still No. 5 in its sixth week, and leads Amazon's US espionage chart. Read it as a fast, dark spy thriller rather than a courtroom drama and it is hard to put down.
Reader review (1)
Reviews from visitors. Checked automatically; names are not shown.
A reader ·
An American couple – Paul and Chelsea Tanner – set off to Paris for a dream honeymoon. They both come from loving families, Paul’s family in particular also being pretty well-heeled. Chelsea has a significant social media profile, and as a result their hugely detailed itinerary is available to all. But events in Paris are quickly going to take a turn for the worse. In what appears to be a carefully constructed operation, the pair are abducted and their parents are about to receive some devastating news. As the situation is digested and further information is sought by the impacted families, it becomes apparent that this might not be the first time an almost identical event has occurred. But what are common elements and who are the perpetrators? Also, what happened to those previously captured? Unfortunately, there are too many questions and far too few answers. Difficult choices will have to be made, yet with no guarantee of a successful outcome. Grisham manages to keep the tension at fever pitch as we watch events unfold from various standpoints. It all feels grimly realistic and it’s hard to see how this can end well for the victims and their families. I worked through this tale in the course of a few days, finding it hard to put down. The construction and execution of the story is, I think, beyond reproach. My only slight reservation is that to a large extent this is a story of bad news, pain and grief. There are few light moments here. Yet, it remains a brilliantly told thriller of a novel with an ending that felt both surprising and yet at the same time satisfyingly credible.




